NIT Shop
 

  
  NIT Shop

  Subscriptions
  Blog  
  Breaking News

  News

  Opinion
  The Arts
  Classroom

  Business
  Community
  Sport
  Travel
  ePostcard
  Links
  Back Issues
  Photo Gallery
  About Us
  Jobs   Downloads  

  issue 208








* A NOTE TO OUR ONLINE READERS:

The multi-award winning National Indigenous Times is an independent newspaper and receives no government funding whatsoever. Our print edition is published every fortnight, but because of the public interest nature of our reporting, we ensure all of our stories are available online at no cost. Thus, we rely entirely on advertising and subscriptions to survive, and hope you'll consider subscribing to NIT's print edition to help us continue our work, or even just browse our Online Shop.

  News

 

Shadow Attorney-General George Brandis' reasons for opposing the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples are "wrong", Indigenous law expert Megan Davis says.

Brandis' UN Declaration claims "wrong", says Aboriginal law expert
Issue 148 - 06 Mar 2008

By Adam Gartrell

CANBERRA, March 11, 2008: The federal government has rejected opposition claims that Aboriginal law could be elevated above national law if Australia endorses the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

Shadow Attorney-General George Brandis says he will ask his front bench to oppose the government's plans to endorse the declaration.

Senator Brandis, a barrister, says he believes endorsing the document could have unintended consequences and references to self-determination could give customary law precedence over state law.

Australia, under the Howard government, was one of just four countries to vote against the non-binding declaration - which sets out the rights of the world's estimated 370 million Indigenous people - in September last year.

The Rudd government has promised to endorse the declaration but has not said when.

Minister for Indigenous Affairs Jenny Macklin yesterday said the declaration had "important symbolic value" for Indigenous people but would have no effect on Australian law.

"Labor has already made it plain that we will not be changing any Australian laws in response to the UN declaration," Ms Macklin said.

Megan Davis, director of the Indigenous Law Centre at the University of NSW, said Senator Brandis' claims were completely baseless.

"It's just a completely incorrect reading of the declaration, and he really needs to seek legal advice because it's just specious reasoning," Ms Davis said.

"It's absolutely impossible that this declaration could allow Aboriginal customary law to be elevated above state law. It's just wrong."

She said the declaration clearly protected territorial integrity and sovereignty. - AAP


For more information on the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, please see the related links.


Related Links

http://www.nit.com.au/news/story.aspx?id=14303
http://www.nit.com.au/News/story.aspx?id=14162
http://www.nit.com.au/News/story.aspx?id=12817

Printer Friendly Version  Email Story to a FriendSubmit Letter to Editor

 

  More News

A bland election that has ignored Australia's black issues
Looking up to the future: Garma 2010
Indigenous Australia not invited to the parties
Samantha is a model star
Martin Nakata to head university's Nura Gili program
A New Milestone for Young Indigenous Leader
Mr Donegan named winner of 2010 Telstra Art Award
Liberals match Labor Promise
Kim Hill leads Land Councils' criticism of mining exploration
Indigenous anger grows as mining expands
Deadly disease goes untreated in Aboriginal kids
Koongarra to be protected site forever: Garrett
Land Council happy with Koongarra protection
Kado Muir says let's have dedicated Indigenous seats
All white on the night for Australian elections
Gooda says it's now right time for Rights Act
Indigenous Music Awards set to rock and roll at a gala event in Darwin
Greg's one decision that changed his life
Amnesty calls for end to policies of discrimination
Greens target Indigenous health issues
Rare Indigenous art found in school cupboard
Patrick Dodson hails Yawuru agreement a momentous day
Report highlights plight of Victoria's Indigenous youth
Macklin's $6m grant to Territory Foundation is welcome news
Poll that matters uninspiring to say the least
Tony Currie